A conversation with … Gary Conklin, Conklin Dairy, Plain City

Editor’s note: Due to death threats received by the Conklin family, a photo has not been included. Conklin was recently cleared by a Union County grand jury in an animal-abuse case involving his farm and a video released by Mercy For Animals.

OCJ: What is your family’s history in the dairy Industry?

Gary: The business started in 1919 marketing all types of livestock. Over time the business evolved into just Holstein heifers and cows. Up until 1990 a large part of our sales were from public auctions. Since that point it has been primarily private treaty sales.

OCJ: Will you please describe your dairy operation?

Gary: We broker close up and fresh Holstein heifers. We freshen out 1,000 to 1,200 first calf heifers per year. Many of our customers prefer to acquire fresh heifers. But, we do have some that prefer to buy springing heifers 30 to 60 days from calving.

OCJ: When did you first see the video compiled by Mercy for Animals?

Gary: On the afternoon of May 25, 2010, I was traveling in Ohio when I received a call from a reporter asking for my comments regarding the YouTube video that had surfaced. Upon arriving home in the evening I immediately watched the video and felt absolute devastation and disbelief over the horrific abuse being shown by one of the company’s former employees.

OCJ: What was your initial reaction?

Gary: I immediately notified the Union County Sheriff’s Department giving them a heads up to the situation and asked for their presence on the farm Wednesday, May 26 at 6 a.m. Billy Joe Gregg arrived on the farm where he was escorted in and immediately terminated. It was at that time the Sheriff’s Department began their interrogation, which ultimately led to the arrest of Billy Joe Gregg.

OCJ: Why was Billy Joe Gregg hired on your farm?

Gary: Billy Joe was hired in early November 2009. He lived near by, was attending a local community college and was looking for a job. He was raised on his family’s dairy farm in Michigan and was familiar not only with dairy cattle but with the equipment used on a farm. He also had an extensive farm background, worked on several other farms and was an Iraqi War veteran.

OCJ: Can you explain the footage that reportedly shows you “kicking a downed cow”?

Gary: That heifer had just calved and was compromised from a health standpoint. She was weak, and if she continued to lay down there was the chance she would lose feeling in her legs, and they would become atrophied. Chances of her survival diminished the longer she was down. In Grand Jury testimony all veterinary experts testified that actions taken were not only appropriate but necessary for the well being and survival of the cow. Unfortunately, the videotape put me in between two beatings, making the immediate action taken shown to look abusive.

Additionally, the undercover videographer in his signed statement indicated that he had never witnessed me abusing any animals and that I was not aware of the abuse committed by Billy Joe Gregg. Also, further statements revealed the undercover videographer was in contact daily with organizations supporting his undercover abuse investigation. At no time was the abuse of farm animals brought to my attention, or that of the Humane Society or Sheriff’s Department. Had that been the case, and reports of the first signs of abuse been brought to our attention, immediate action would have been taken against both employees and it would not have developed into the devastation that so greatly affected our reputable business, my family and an entire community. Abuse and filming continued for an additional three weeks until it aired on the Internet.

OCJ: Strong police action prevented your farm from reportedly being demolished by animal rights activists on Memorial Day. What was that like?

Gary: The Union County Sheriff’s Department indicated from heavy activity on the Internet that animal rights activists from all over the country were scheduled to arrive on the farm with the intent to destroy Conklin Dairy Farms “piece by piece.” Given the level and number of threats to our farm, family and community officials, in an effort to protect people and property, law enforcement made the decision on how to handle the situation. They were doing their jobs based on the high level of threatening activity to all who were involved in the investigation.

OCJ: In hindsight, what recommendation would you give other farmers for their protection against animal rights activists?

Gary: Given the events that affected our family farm these past few months I offer the following recommendations:

A. Develop an employee handbook, which would cover in detail employee job descriptions, animal handling practices, animal health protocols, general company policies as well as consequences for violation of those policies. This process would include the employee signing off that they have read the handbook and know they will be held accountable to those policies.

B. Establish and review with all employees the animal abuse policy, which states any animal abuse is intolerable. If you witness abuse of any animals by a company employee it is to be reported to farm management immediately. The result in failure to make that report would be termination of employment.  Policies are posted throughout the farm operation facility.

C. Put in place a policy that states the use of cameras and recording devices without the written permission of management is strictly prohibited and, if done, all pictures and recordings are property of the employer.

D. As the agricultural and dairy industries continue to change, management must be diligent in updating and changing policies as they affect operations, then effectively communicate those changes with all farm staff.

Check Also

Farmland losses far outpace preservation

By Matt Reese Ohio farmland is a long taken-for-granted resource providing the very basis for …


  1. Mr. Conklin’s response was appropriate and professional. Much more so than the initiatives undertaken by Mercy for Animals. Authorities should have been alerted immediatly by the Mercy witness. Threats of violence and retaliation are unacceptable. Politics is clearly at work here, including an upcoming ballot initiative in Ohio. The hype and hysteria over this issue was nearly comical. I feel for the Conklin family. This must have been a nightmare.

    • I wonder what you think the cows felt? I don’t think they give a fuck about politics. I agree that unlawful violence is unacceptable. That is why the law should be invoked to cause Conklin to be removed from dairy farming permanently. He has a childish, mentally unstable anger – hitting a cow in the face with a crowbar because it was “pissing me off”. IF you are a farmer do you really want this cruelty to be representative of your “expertise”?

      • Debbi and Andy I agree with you. It is his responsibility to know what happens in his business at all times. Excuses only satisfy those who make them and I do not buy his excuses. These animals were pocked with pitchforks, stomped on, punched full forced and kicked severely by ‘the scum worker’, did he not ever question swollen calves heads, puncture wounds, sores, wounds on the cattle? Come off it!!! HE KNEW WHAT WAS HAPPENING !~Gary himself was caught on that tape abusing these animals. He must be arrested along with those thugs he hired and tried for animal abuse. The farms should be put out of business and everyone boycott it until it is !

    • I do not feel for him. In this interview his advice to other business’s is to prohibit video without permission from management… had it NOT BEEN for that video the abuse would possibly STILL be going on at his farm… so basically hes just sorry that he got caught by video… THANK GOD FOR THAT VIDEO. IT PROBABLY SAVED LOTS OF COWS N CALFS

    • Why is it OK to KICK a cow to get it to stand.. There has got to be a better…more humane…and NON- ABUSIVE way to get tbe cow to stand if needed. When you go to the doctor would the DR. Kick you to get you up if he needed you to FOR YOUR HEALTH… THIS IS HIS EXCUSE fot abuse??

    • Gary says that he had to kick the heifer to stand. Well the Heifer probably was unable to stand due to getting hit in the head with a crowbar or from any of the other types of abuse she had endured. This farm needs to be completely SHUT DOWN. And Gary needs to get prosecuted for participating in this abuse and for ALLOWING it to go on… He is the owner …he knows what goes on in his busines. And instead of prohibiting video. He needs to install video so he can view everything that happens.. most business’s have security cameras..He just has something hes hiding or TRYING TO

    • Pamela Torgersen

      Did you see the video? If so, you are as responsible as Conklin for horrific abuse to an animal.

  2. I think you should have asked Conklin why he never noticed such obvious abuse on his cattle, marks etc. These animals were pocked with pitchforks, stomped on, punched full forced and kicked severly by ‘the scum worker’, did he not ever question swollen calves heads, puncture wonds, sores, wounds on the cattle? Come off it!!! He may not have taken part in the abuse(i couldnt watch the video anymore, so i will trust the judment he acting appropriatly when trying to get the downed cow to stand), but i and many others cannot accept that he was not aware that abuse was rife. Also the story of the pit of dead cattle. What happened to these cattle, why dispose of them, why didnt they go for meat slaughter? Were they so severly beaten, that they were just disreguared and hidden, and the problem buried. These questions deserve to be answered, even a year on from this tragedy

  3. There is only one reason a farmer does not want recordings of his actions, and that is because he fears he is breaking the law. The same avoidance of responsibility is the cause of innocent, unarmed youths being shot to death by police. The same “secret society” attitude where these pathetic excuses for men congratulate each other for lying. I presume that if Conklin were asked, he would claim to be a God Fearing man. If that were true he should be shitting in his pants. Does he know that the devil is often portrayed as cloven footed and Bull-like ? He’ll get he just deserts – hopefully with a crowbar.

  4. What a douche hole this interviewer is. Gary himself was caught on that tape abusing these animals. If I ever see Gary Conklin face to face, he’d better hope I’m in a great mood and able to have tons of restraint.

  5. Simply put if your not doing anything wrong why prohibit recording devices and demand ownership of any video taken……. Hmmmmm

  6. Eye for an Eye is what needs to be done to these sorry sacks of shit. I cant wait to find them all. Their lives will be destroyed one way or another.

  7. This guy will burn in hell for his treatment of animals. I pray Karma will bring an early death!

  8. My family also raised plenty of cattle. The guy is full of sh*t! We never once needed to kick our animals for any reason. How many of these so called “veterinarians” really testified on his behalf? Also, money can keep a lot of people silent. Mr. Conklin has plenty of it. ?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *