Opinion: Medicare disadvantage

By Chris Gibbs

It was early this past October, on a Saturday, when Dad called to ask if I could take him to the eye doctor the following Tuesday. He was having trouble seeing out of his right eye and decided not to drive. “Sure,” I said. “I’ll pick you up, and maybe we’ll do the Waffle House after.”

When I arrived Tuesday morning, he was dressed, but was unusually unstable as we maneuvered into the truck and off to the doctor. “Chris, your dad has had a stroke, and it probably occurred last week. He’s lost total vision in his right eye, and it’s irreparable. I’m obligated to send him directly to the emergency room for examination,” said the optometrist.

The diagnosis would launch us both into a maze of administrative and gut-wrenching twists and turns, seemingly designed to confuse and frustrate, rather than care. All of this was brought about by a change in healthcare providers made years ago.

After four days in the ICU, Dad was on his way to rehab. Thankfully, he and Mom had moved to what is arguably the premier retirement community and care campus in the county years earlier.

Six hours into care, the wheels fell off. “Chris, did you know your dad doesn’t have Medicare as his primary care provider; he has Medicare Advantage?” the administrator informed. After rummaging through insurance cards and billing statements, it was clear that Mom and Dad were lured into the promise that Medicare Advantage plans promote. That single nuance of who’s the primary insurer launched us (me) into an eleven-month, full-time administrative battle for seamless care. That battle was not with Medicare or the rehab facility, but with the private, ‘for-profit’ insurance provider.

On paper, Medicare Advantage plans can appear appealing. Insurance companies advertise “extra” benefits like dental or vision coverage, and the convenience of having all services bundled under one plan. But when the rubber meets the road in situations requiring a rehab facility after a hospital stay, one learns quickly that these plans can provide more barriers than benefits.

Under traditional Medicare, coverage rules are pretty straightforward. If a parent needs skilled nursing or rehabilitation after a qualifying hospital stay, traditional Medicare is relatively predictable.

With Medicare Advantage, the experience can be far different. Private insurers run Medicare Advantage plans, and while they must provide at least the same coverage as traditional Medicare, they use strict rules, prior authorizations, and narrow provider networks that can drastically limit options.

In our case, the nuance of difference wasn’t clear until Dad left the hospital and needed a rehab stay. In a Medicare Advantage plan, the insurer, not the doctor, decides if rehab is “medically necessary” and for how long. Denials come swiftly, even when care providers recommend continued care. The first denial from Medicare Advantage came at us three days in, without the rehab facility ever being asked to provide an initial assessment of Dad’s condition.

They tipped their hand there, that saving money was the priority, not the patient. That was the easiest appeal to win. It got progressively more complicated from there. In one of the appeals, Medicare Advantage denied rehab for Dad because, as he was relearning to walk with a walker, he had managed to travel 90 feet. In the prep for the appeal, I quizzed the reviewer, “So what’s the standard for denying care? Is it 50 feet, 80 feet, or maybe 89 feet?” I wanted to know so I could gauge the durability of my argument. I was told to review a bulletin issued by Medicare. We won the appeal.

I remember lamenting to close friends more than once that without someone on top of their game to advocate for a Medicare Advantage patient, the patient would be swept into a doom loop of incomplete care and the possibility of financial ruin. Determining if my Dad was going to receive proper care was never the issue. At issue was who would pay for it: Medicare Advantage, Medicare, or him.

I’m not here to imply that Medicare Advantage plans operate in bad faith. Some, and hopefully most, provide good networks and responsive customer service. But the reality is, these plans are structured around cost control, not open-ended access to care. That structure is at odds with what many families need when dealing with sudden health crises in older age.

So you might be thinking, well, let’s switch back to Medicare when and if a higher level of care is necessary. But beware. By the time adult children step in to help, it’s often too late to switch back easily. Medicare has specific enrollment windows, and moving from Medicare Advantage to traditional Medicare can be complicated and time-consuming.

In the end, the problem isn’t the Medicare Advantage product, it’s the mismatch between what seniors think they’re buying and what they get. For families, that mismatch becomes painfully apparent when trying to navigate rehab and long-term care needs.

So my cautionary tale is one of awareness and preparation. If you have aging parents, have the Medicare conversation now. Ask about their coverage, explain the differences, and make sure they understand the potential trade-offs of Medicare Advantage versus traditional Medicare. It may feel uncomfortable, but it’s far better to have that talk before a health crisis strikes than to be standing in a hospital or rehab facility hallway, arguing with an insurance company, your siblings, or both about the next step in your parent’s care.

Dad passed away this past weekend.

~ And that’s the way I see it from where I sit.

Gibbs is a farmer and lives in Maplewood, Ohio. He and his family own and operate 560 acres of crops, hay, and cattle. Gibbs is retired from the United States Department of Agriculture and currently serves as President of the Gateway Arts Council, Chairman of the Shelby County Democratic Party, and President of Rural Voices USA and Rural Voices Network.

The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of Ohio’s Country Journal or Ohio Ag Net or its staff.

Check Also

Decades of dedication: Pat McConnell honored as LICA Lady of the Year

By Wyatt Morrow, OCJ Field Reporter Pat McConnell had no reason to believe the award …