Bob and Donna Peters have built an award-winning flock and family at their farm in Dawn, Ohio.

Robert and Donna Peters honored with 2025 Charles Boyles Master Shepherd Award

By Joel Penhorwood

If you spend any time in the sheep barn at the Great Darke County Fair, you probably already know Robert and Donna Peters. And if you don’t, you’ve certainly felt their influence in the sheep, the shows, and the young people they’ve supported for more than half a century.

This year, the Ohio Sheep Improvement Association (OSIA) and the Ohio Sheep and Wool Program (OSWP) recognized Robert, known to most as Bob, and Donna with the 2025 Charles Boyles Master Shepherd Award, the highest honor in Ohio’s sheep industry.

On their Dawn-area farm where Bob grew up, the couple reflected on a lifetime rooted in the same place. “We’ve lived here over 55 years,” Bob said. “My parents, my grandparents — all here. We go to bed at Dawn. We get up at Dawn. I’ve lived here all my life, and it’s been a happy life.”

Donna, who grew up in nearby Coldwater, agreed, “We raised our four children here and a lot of sheep. It’s been a good time.”

Visitors to the Peters farm can’t miss the iconic mural on their barn: a larger-than-life Annie Oakley that faces the road. But the huge painting takes second place to the great memories that have happened within the barns of the Peters family.

Bob’s sheep story has a special beginning. He didn’t start with lambs as the family was known for dairy cattle. As a young boy, his uncle gave him a horned Dorset lamb for his birthday. That’s when the story took a fun turn.

“We had acquired a duck… and to keep the lamb company, she threw the duck in with him. They became life partners,” Bob said.

When he showed that first lamb at the county fair, the duck insisted on coming too.

The infamous Tuffy and Tippy, a horned Dorset and duck duo who were inseparable.

“The lamb wasn’t happy and the duck wasn’t happy at home, so they brought the duck to the fair,” Donna said. “When he showed the lamb, the duck waddled out after it right into the show ring.”

The pair, named Tuffy and Tippy, became local legends and that same year, Bob unexpectedly won champion market lamb. He didn’t realize it came with a sale, where the lamb brought $1.25 per pound. What he didn’t know until later was that his parents went to the market and bought the lamb back for $0.14 per pound so it could return home. “That’s how I got started,” Bob said.

Bob started showing at the Ohio State Fair in 1973 and hasn’t missed many years since.

“There’s been a lot of fun, some disappointments. When you start at the bottom and get to the top, it’s hard to stay there,” he said. “But the best part is the sheep friends. They really are good people.”

Donna agreed. “So many sheep friends. It’s been a good thing for our family.”

Their Corriedale flock found great success. In 2005, a ram they raised won National Champion, a memorable moment for the family. Today, another generation continues the tradition. Four children – Scott, Jesse, Sara, and Anne – grew up in the Peters barn and the aisles of both the Darke County and Ohio State Fairs.

While they unanimously describe their dad as shy, the moment the Peters siblings learned about Bob being named the Charles Boyles Master Shepherd Award winner, their reactions were immediate.

“He’ll be so proud,” Scott said. “Getting him up in front of everybody will be a chore, but he will be so proud.”

“He’s done so much for the industry,” Sara added. “He’s brought so many people into loving sheep. It’s not something he does for money or popularity. He truly loves being in the barn with the sheep and talking to the people.”

His children joked that their dad is so dedicated that they once figured, if their mom ever passed during fair week, “the viewing would have to be at the fairgrounds because we don’t think Dad would leave.”

Their family trips weren’t beach vacations; they were weeks spent camping at the fairgrounds and sleeping in the barns. “We’d stay for the whole fair,” Jesse said. “I can still hear the echoes of the sheep all night long.” Scott remembers the Volkswagen Rabbit trips to Missouri with tall teenage boys stretched across the seats because the car got “incredible miles per gallon.”

Champion lambs were a normal part of growing up.

“We just grew up winning champion lamb every year,” Scott said. One year he sold his champion to Gov. Jim Rhodes for $13.75 per pound, far above the record at the time. “I didn’t start crying until I saw Dad crying,” he said. The governor returned the lamb and the Peters resold it to benefit the local 4-H community.

Bob is now a fixture of the Darke County Fair sheep barn, helping run the barn, coordinating judges, handling entries, and keeping the operation moving.

“We have good men there, and we spend a lot of time getting ready for the fair,” Bob said. “If we weren’t at the fair, I don’t know what we’d do.”

Across all the stories, what rises to the top is Bob and Donna’s compassion for animals and people.

“Doesn’t matter if it’s the worst lamb in the barn — he wants that little lamb to make it,” Sara said.

Jesse remembers bottle lambs in the bathtub, sweaters knitted for the weak ones, and lambs warming by the fireplace. “Mom is the real master shepherd in a lot of ways,” he said. “She guided Dad along his path and then kept all of his dreams lined up and headed in the right direction and kept his family flock guided and headed in the right direction, too.”

Today, many of their 16 grandchildren show at the county fair. Bob helps raise the lambs, just as he has for countless 4-H kids.

Family friend Gary Phlipot said his family is just one of many influenced by the Peters.

“We knew nothing about sheep,” Phlipot said. “Bob helped us get started. Long story short, the cattle are gone and the sheep are there and thriving. He’s helped a lot of young people. Probably more than he realizes.

Phlipot noted Bob’s influence reaches well beyond Darke County.

“He’s been very influential all over the United States. He’s helped a lot of people — probably more than he realizes,” he said. “They’re just really good people. If you meet them, you’d like them instantly.”

Roger High, executive director of OSIA and OSWP, said Bob and Donna fit the mold exactly for the Master Shepherd Award.

“This is the pinnacle award in Ohio’s sheep industry. Bob and Donna fit right in with the very best we’ve ever honored,” he said. “They’ve been very involved in Darke County for many years…providing lambs to their grandchildren, helping at the Ohio State Fair, and staying active in the Corriedale world.

“Their wealth of knowledge and their leadership have been very impactful.”

High works hard to keep the award a surprise for honorees until its presentation at the Buckeye Shepherd’s Symposium, but the Peters say awards of any kind take second place to the journey.

Awards, though, aren’t what matter most to the Peters. “It’s not so much the blue ribbon,” Bob said. “It’s the people you meet — the lasting friends.” Donna added, “Win or lose, it’s a good thing for your family. To see the work it takes to come out with a good product.”

Their children may have said it best. “He’s not just a shepherd in the barn,” Sara said. “He’s a shepherd to his family.”

Check Also

Featured Audio: Putting technology to work for a sustainable cattle business

Brent Porteus and his family are exploring how technology can improve efficiency and help their …