By Mike Zuzolo, Global Commodity Analytics & Consulting LLC
The United States and Israel’s move against Iran is threatening the flow of oil out of the Persian Gulf. History provides several examples of how markets react to these types of oil-driven rallies.
Since 1973, several oil price spikes have occurred when the market feared supply disruptions from the Middle East. However, the current situation has two key differences that make it unique.
First, there is the possibility of a complete closure of the Strait of Hormuz, which would significantly disrupt global oil shipments. Second, Iran appears to lack strong regional support compared to past conflicts.
These two differences (as I see them) are key to answering the ultimate market question: What puts the ‘high’ in crude oil prices? Without regime change in Iran, the only other likely option for reopening the Strait is to escort energy ships safely through it.
As I go to print this month’s outlook, President Trump is calling on other countries to join the United States in helping secure the Strait of Hormuz so vessels can have safe passage. But the key point of the current conflict, as with other major conflicts in this region in the past, is to remove the threat of supply uncertainty. (The issue of Iran’s nuclear material is really the most important issue to me ultimately, but I don’t think that the market has decided to take this up at this point. Because of this, we’ll leave it on the side this month.)
Assuming the above to be correct, it makes sense that the longer the Strait of Hormuz is closed, unused, and threatened, the higher and longer crude oil and natural gas prices are likely to remain in place.
Research I conducted for a recent client webinar offers a useful comparison. When Russia invaded Ukraine in 2022, the global oil market estimated that roughly 3 million barrels per day of crude and refined products were removed from the market. At the time, WTI crude rallied from about $75 per barrel at the end of 2021 — as traders began watching Russia mobilize near Ukraine’s border — to $130.50 per barrel. That roughly 3% loss of global supply pushed prices up 74%.
Looking at past oil price shocks, moves of 60% or more are not unusual, suggesting the market’s reaction to the invasion largely followed historical patterns.
In the current conflict, the International Energy Agency estimates potential disruptions of about 8.5 million barrels per day, with roughly 1.5 million barrels per day of Iranian oil moving through the Strait of Hormuz. Since the end of January, WTI crude has risen about $54.27 per barrel, climbing roughly 83% to a recent high of $119.48 (see chart). In many ways, the market’s response is tracking closely with previous oil shocks.

During the past two decades, crude oil has shown how volatile these markets can be. The lead-month high reached $147.27 per barrel in 2008, while the market plunged to an unprecedented negative $40.32 per barrel in April 2020.
The “genie” coming out of the “bottle”:
If the Strait remains shut for the rest of March and into April, even more demand-rationing is likely to be seen by the futures market.I am suggesting to clients and subscribers that around $100 a barrel could be the new support for the market if we are still contending with this problem a month from now. Similarly, with the support and positive price relationship with the WTI, if drought conditions continue to prevail in the HRW wheat-belt here in the United States — coupled with potential planting delays in the Black Sea Region — I think the new support for U.S. wheat futures could be around $6/Bu. In this environment, while I’ve been correct in my expectation of lower cattle prices due to weakening equities and strengthening grain prices, I am putting my cattle hedging program on hold for now. I could see worsening drought conditions and higher grain prices forcing dressed weights lower, with marketings likely to be pulled forward. Remaining current for now seems a good course of action.
Sign up for a two-week free trial of my midday audio & afternoon blog post at www.globalcommresearch.com.
Disclaimer: There is a significant risk of loss in trading futures & options on futures, and it may not be suitable for all investors. Investors should consider the risks involved and evaluate their suitability based on their financial conditions. Past performance is not indicative of future results.
Mike Zuzolo has been a licensed Series 3 broker & analyst in commodities since 1995 and is the founder of Global Commodity Analytics & Consulting LLC. A native of Preble County, OH, Mike and his family have lived in NE Kansas since 2013. You can sign up for a free trial of his analysis at www.globalcommresearch.com.
Ohio Ag Net | Ohio's Country Journal Ohio Ag Net | Ohio's Country Journal 